Stories/ 子不语/ The God Who Gave a False Verdict

The God Who Gave a False Verdict

关神断狱

SourceZibuyu (What the Master Would Not Discuss)
AuthorYuan Mei
EraQing dynasty · Qianlong era, c. 1736–1788
Writtenc. 1788
DeityJusticeGhost

Ma Feng of Liyang was a provincial graduate without office, tutoring in the house of a family named Li in the west village.

A neighbour named Wang was a violent man who beat his wife. His wife was starving and had nothing, and she stole a chicken from the Li household and cooked it. The Li family found out and told her husband. He was drunk. In a rage he took a knife and dragged his wife over, and once he had the facts out of her he was going to kill her.

In her terror the wife accused Ma Feng of stealing the chicken.

Ma argued and could not prove himself.

“There is a shrine of Lord Guan in the village,” he said. “Let us go and cast the blocks. If they fall yin, the woman stole it. If they fall yang, the man did.”

They cast three times. All three came up yang.

Wang dropped the knife and let his wife go home. And Ma Feng, on account of a stolen chicken, was despised by the whole village and lost his tutoring post for years.

Some time after, a medium was holding a planchette, and the god who came was Lord Guan. Ma Feng, remembering, roundly abused the god for his inaccuracy. The planchette wrote in the ash:

Ma Feng. You will one day hold authority over people. Do you not understand that some matters are urgent and others can wait? You stealing a chicken costs you a post. That woman stealing a chicken dies at once under a knife. I would rather bear the name of being wrong and save a living life. God Above noted that I understand the weight of things, and promoted me three grades. And you resent me?

Ma said: “Lord Guan has been made an emperor. What grades are left to rise?”

The god wrote:

Now, in all the nine provinces there is a shrine of Lord Guan. How should there be enough Lords Guan to go round and share the offerings? Every village shrine has been set up by order of God Above, and in each one some ghost of that place who was upright in life is appointed to do the work. The real Lord Guan stands at the left hand of God. How would he have time to come down into the world?

Ma Feng was convinced.

Original classical Chinese text · 原文

汝窃鸡,不过失馆;某妻窃鸡,立死刀下矣。我宁受不灵之名,以救生人之命。上帝念我能识政体,故超升三级。……今四海九州皆有关神庙,焉得有许多关神分享血食。凡村乡所立关庙,皆奉上帝命,择里中鬼平生正直者代司其事,真关神在帝左右,何能降凡耶?

From 《关神断狱》, Zibuyu juan 2. The second answer is one of the most useful pieces of divine-administration lore in the collection.

Source. From Zibuyu (What the Master Would Not Discuss) (子不语), by Yuan Mei , c. 1788. The original text is in the public domain; this English rendering and the accompanying notes are original work.

Keep Reading

Related Stories

Qing dynasty · late 17th century · 聊斋志异

The Cricket

促织

The emperor loves cricket-fighting, so every district must supply fighting crickets. One ruined family is saved by a champion the size of a man's little finger — which may be the soul of their dying son.

TransformationJustice
Eastern Jin dynasty · 4th century · 搜神记

The Two Swords

干将莫邪(三王墓)

The smith Gan Jiang forges two perfect swords for the King of Chu and is murdered for it. His son Chi grows up to seek vengeance — and a stranger in black offers to do it for him, asking only the boy's head and his sword.

SwordJustice
Eastern Jin dynasty · 4th century · 搜神记

The Husband-and-Wife Tree

韩凭夫妇

The King of Song takes the beautiful wife of his retainer Han Ping. The lovers die defying him and are buried apart — and their graves grow two trees that bend across the road to intertwine.

LoveTransformationJustice