Stories/ 子不语/ The True Judge Bao and the False

The True Judge Bao and the False

真龙图变假龙图

SourceZibuyu (What the Master Would Not Discuss)
AuthorYuan Mei
EraQing dynasty · Qianlong era, c. 1736–1798
Writtenc. 1788
JusticeSatireOfficialdomGhost
A village opera stage at night with a painted judge in a black cap and red robe seated in judgement, a returning traveller with a bundle staring up in horror from the crowd, a well with a wind-devil rising behind
Illustration generated by AI, based on the ancient Chinese text.

A man named Song of Jiaxing was magistrate of Xianyou. He was austerely upright by habit and styled himself Old Bao.

In one of the villages there was a certain Wang, a student of the Imperial College, who was in love with the wife of one of his tenant farmers; the two were well suited, and being annoyed that the husband was at home, Wang bribed a fortune-teller to tell the man that his year was unlucky for staying at home and that he must travel far afield if he were to escape harm. The husband believed it. He went and told Wang, and Wang lent him capital and sent him to trade in Sichuan.

Three years went by and he did not come back, and the village passed the word around that the tenant had been murdered by Wang.

Song had heard something of this, and wanted to right the wrong. One day, passing through the village, a whirlwind rose in front of his sedan chair. He followed where it went, and it came out of a well. He had runners dredge the well, and a man’s decayed body was brought up, which he took to be the missing tenant. So he arrested Wang and the tenant’s wife, and had them interrogated under severe torture. Both confessed to having murdered the husband, and were dealt with according to law.

The people of the district called him Judge Bao. They made a play of it and sang it from village to village.

A year later the husband came back from Sichuan. He had no sooner entered the town than he saw the affair of Wang being acted on a stage. He stood and watched it, and learned that his wife had already died for a crime that was not hers.

He broke down on the spot, and carried his outcry to the provincial capital. The surveillance commissioner tried the case, and Magistrate Song answered for it with his life, under the statute on causing death by deliberately torturing the innocent.

And the people of Xianyou made a song about it:

Talked of a lover murdering a husband — and the true Dragon Diagram became the false. A word to all who are set over the people in this world: do not lean on clean hands and think that makes you bold.

Original classical Chinese text · 原文

嘉兴宋某,为仙游令,平素峭洁,以「包老」自命。某村有王监生者,奸佃户之妻,两情相得,嫌其本夫在家,乃贿算命者告其夫以「在家流年不利,必远游他方,才免于难」,本夫信之。告王监生,王遂借本钱,令贸易四川。三年不归,村人相传:某佃户被王监生谋死矣。宋素闻此事,欲雪其冤。一日,过某村,有旋风起于轿前。迹之,风从井中出。差人撩井,得男子腐尸,信为某佃,遂拘王监生与佃妻,严刑拷讯。俱自认谋害本夫,置之于法。邑人称为「宋龙图」,演成戏本,沿村弹唱。 又一年,其夫从四川归。甫入城,见戏台上演王监生事,就观之,方知己妻业已冤死。登时大恸,号控于省城。臬司某为之审理,宋令以故勘平人致死抵罪。仙游人为之歌曰:「瞎说奸夫害本夫,真龙图变假龙图。寄言人世司民者,莫恃官清胆气粗。」

From 《真龙图变假龙图》, Zibuyu juan 9. Translated in full, including the closing ballad. 龍圖, Dragon Diagram, was Bao Zheng's honorific; a 監生 is a purchased student of the Imperial College.

Source. From Zibuyu (What the Master Would Not Discuss) (子不语), by Yuan Mei , c. 1788. The original text is in the public domain; this English rendering and the accompanying notes are original work.

Keep Reading

Related Stories

Qing dynasty · late 17th century · 聊斋志异

Xi Fangping Sues the Underworld

席方平

A son follows his murdered father into the Courts of the Dead and files a lawsuit — through every clerk, every magistrate, every torture the underworld can devise, up to the highest god there is.

UnderworldJusticeGhost
Qing dynasty · Qianlong era, c. 1736–1798 · 谐铎

The Litigation Writers

讼师说讼

A father and son who write lawsuits for hire are dragged before Yama, who asks them how they do it. They explain, at length and with examples. He gouges out the father's eyes and cuts off the son's arms. It makes no difference at all.

SatireJusticeUnderworld
Qing dynasty · Qianlong era, c. 1736–1798 · 子不语

Intercession in the Underworld

赵文华在阴司说情

A man and a serving-maid are dragged before the court of the dead and confess. The sentence is about to be pronounced when a card comes in: Minister Zhao Wenhua is here. The judge rises, goes out, and comes back with the charge reduced by three degrees. The family has no idea why a Ming minister should be shielding them.

JusticeUnderworldSatire